FollowThe increasing success of French bred horses has been the most striking element of National Hunt breeding over the last decade. Mon Mome in the Grand National, Binocular and Hors la Loi in the Champion Hurdle, Kauto Star in the Gold Cup and Master Minded, Voy Pur Ustedes and Azertyuiop in the Queen Mother Champion Chase have taken jumps racing top prizes. Trainers and owners aren’t oblivious to such success and the respective champion trainers Paul Nicholls and Willie Mullins are long time converts to the merits of French breds. The Irish and British breeding sectors do not seem to have actively responded to the new market realities and if nothing is done they will continue to lose market share. If the Anglo- Irish racing and breeding authorities wish to meet the challenge they need to think strategically and act courageously.
Understanding the marketplace
Someone once explained the difference between advertising and marketing as follows- with advertising you try and sell what you’ve made, with marketing you only make what you can sell. With respect to Irish Thoroughbred Marketing and British Bloodstock Marketing they are actually in the advertising game trying to promote a product that has already been produced. Their governing bodies need to think about true marketing and how their respective breeding and racing industries can produce and showcase products that are truly in demand.
The French breds that are in demand in the UK and Ireland have previously demonstrated ability on the racecourse. For a buyer this means that the horses are broken, schooled, fit and ready to run and yet they are at an age when many of their Anglo-Irish peers are still being left to develop. The problem for the Anglo-Irish store horse is that the evidence in favour of this model versus the French model is inconclusive at best. However there can be no doubt in an owner’s mind regarding the costs and time involved in bringing his store horse to the racetrack. The traditionalists used to argue that horses who had started “too early” would burn out quickly but the racing careers of such as Kauto Star (36 runs over 8 seasons and counting), Big Bucks (30 runs and counting), Mon Mome (41 runs) have changed that assumption. In addition some veterinary evidence may indicate a beneficial impact of early exercise and training on subsequent injury rates.
Meeting the challenge- race planners
Underpinning the French system is the race programme that provides lots of opportunities to test younger horses. There is no reason why elements of the French racing programme cannot be adopted by the Anglo-Irish race-planners. It might horrify some (or many), but why not run three year old bumpers, three year old hurdles from February onwards and four year old chases on a regular basis? The world would not end and traditional race programming would still exist for less precocious types. In a business situation rather than allowing a competitor an unchallenged position you would seek to win back the business and such moves would allow a segment of the market to compete directly with the French runners. An additional benefit of such moves is that it would allow breeders earlier indications of the merits of jumping stallions. Given that many jumps stallions are deceased before their worth has been established this is another important consideration.
Meeting the challenge- breeders
1. I don’t believe that French jumps stallions are manifestly superior to their Anglo-Irish counterparts but there are some lessons that might be learned. Firstly a much greater number of French stallions have actually raced over jumps. In the UK and Ireland the likes of Alderbrook, Midnight Legend, Broadsword and Monksfield performed over jumps but they represented a tiny minority of the stallion population. It seems incongruous that jumps breeders do not seem to place any weighting (and often a negative weighting) on stallions having demonstrated an ability to jump. It is also worth remembering that one of the outstanding steeplechase sires of the modern era, Roselier, won the French champion hurdle.
2. There has been a loss of diversity in the National Hunt stallion ranks. This is driven by huge books for fashionable stallions, many of whom are unproven. There has also been an unhealthy concentration on certain sire lines especially sons of Sadler’s Wells. The consequence is reduced opportunities for other stallions to make a breakthrough. The French have smaller book sizes and many stallions get an opportunity there that would not be available in the UK or Ireland. Irish and UK breeders should be less fashion conscious and more adventurous.
3. Invest in proven French stallions. Larger book sizes give Irish and UK stallion masters an economic advantage over their French rivals. This affords them the opportunity to tap into successful French lines. The purchase of Robin Des Pres and Robin Des Champs for stud duty in Ireland are indicators that some studs are adopting this policy. More studmasters should use this key difference between the marketplaces to their advantage. In a business context this is analogous to poaching your opposition’s key staff, something that can strengthen your position and weaken theirs.
Conclusion
Competition between breeding nations is healthy and can lead to improved standards all round. The French have done a superb job in gaining a very substantial share of the Anglo-Irish market, driven by racecourse success. This success has naturally resulted in higher prices for promising young stock and some purchasers are now questioning whether there is still value to be obtained. However it would be a very dangerous assumption by Anglo-Irish breeders that the French will price themselves out of the market. With the Anglo-Irish industry in crisis, doing nothing is not an option so radical and new thinking is required to regain competitiveness.
I found the above blog very interesting with some very valid points and as I am a NH breeder, it is in my interest that the above topic should reach an improved conclusion sooner rather than later.
I have attended breeding seminars where some of these topics were discussed. I remember Martin Pipe saying how Irish stores took months to get the fat off before he could start to train them and he would like more done with them, and then Tony Mullins said that he would never buy a horse broken but guaranteed untried at any sale.The vet also gave evidence that early training could be beneficial with reguard to injury later on.
I agree that unproven stallions are covering too many large books and it is giving less chances to others.The problem is that unlike the flat, most NH breeders are on a very small scale(and sell as foals) so we don’t really have a choice,when in order to survive we must have stock that are going to be commercial and in demand at the sales.If there is one upside to this over use of some it is that when the lesser used stallions with limited chances do succeed (such as is the case with Stowaway)they prove your point, become commercial and show and are viewed as being top class because they did it the hard way.If we as breeders could pin-point stallions like Stowaway about to “make it” then so would we as we would be in at the bottom fee’s.
With reguard to buying french stallions, would they be for sale ? Would they be as successful here ? One example is Marignan. He was a good racehorse and sire in france but didn’t make it in the UK and dosn’t look like he will hit any highs here in Ireland either.
All the top horses such as Kauto Star etc.. that have been imported overed over the years have a few things in common. They are all bought by leading agents for wealthy oweners and for big powerful yards. These people are not going to a store sale in France hoping to get lucky,rather to pilage the best that they have that are proven.
It is well documented that Kauto Star’s trainer did not want him to be sold, but the power of money made sure he was.It is a fact that the likes of stallions such as Roselier’s jumping ability propably was a factor and help to him getting so many good chasers, but unfortunately the length of time it takes these horses to mature is not what is selling. For the most part most buyers want a horse to run six to nine months after the sale. I really do fear for what staying chasers will look like in a few decades, as very few trainers have oweners willing to wait.They all seem to want speed at the expence of stamina.
Finally on the point of having 3 year old bumpers and hurdles,how will this effect NH breeding and pedigree’s?It will futher increase a need for speed with more flat pedigree influance. I would agree with these type of races, but only for horses that were NH bred so it would be a level playing field and would not dilute great NH pedigree’s.There are plenty example’s of these “flat bred” 3 year olds winning bumpers but they rarely do any good when steped up from 1 mile 6 to two miles plus.If I was to buy a bumper winning filly to go breeding I want to know she stayed beyond a mile and 6.Yes there are exceptions over a mile 6 using the great Istabraq as an example. He won a flat maiden over 1m6f but he is an exception and not the rule.
I would be interested in your views on any points I’ve raised. Keep up the good work.